Thought that sectarianism was a pillar of the Saud Iranian rivalry? Think again, think Kashmir where the two countries’ geopolitical rivalry and Turkish ambitions cross sectarian lines. With Iran, Saudi Arabia and Turkey competing for Indian Kashmiri hearts and minds, Iran and Turkey’s embrace of Kashmiri nationalism is winning them sympathy among both Shiite and Sunni Muslims.
The two countries’ perception of Kashmiri aspirations as nationalist rather than religious gives them a fighting chance to counter long-standing Saudi influence in the troubled South Asian region.
The Kashmiri competition, like Kazakhstan where a Saudi-inspired apolitical and loyalist strand of ultra-conservative Islam has gained popularity, suggests that crown prince Mohammed bin Salman has not given up on religion as a soft power too despite who seeking to root his legitimacy in newly found Saudi nationalism rather than the kingdom’s ultra-conservative interpretation of Islam.
Prince Mohammed, since coming to office in 2015, has significantly cut back on funding and converted the kingdom’s major funding vehicle, the World Muslim League, into a group that sings his praises and propagates tolerance and inter-faith dialogue.
Nevertheless, the crown prince views the promotion of Madkhalism, a particular Saudi strand of ultra-conservatism that preaches absolute obedience to the ruler and sees the kingdom as the model of Islamic governance as a way of countering Iranian activism and the notion of an Islamic republic that recognizes a degree of popular sovereignty.
Saudi Arabia invested an estimated US$100 billion in funding of religious seminaries, cultural and higher educational institutions, media organizations and in a handful of countries militant groups as part of a more than 40-year religiously cloaked, globally waged covert war with Iran. More recently, Turkey has sought to lay claim to leadership of the Muslim world by funding mosques and other institutions across the globe and seizing up Islamic causes like Jerusalem.
The funding, coupled with diplomatic pressure, also aims to counter the far-flung, embattled empire of Fethullah Gulen, an Islamic preacher who lives in exile in Pennsylvania and whom Turkish president Recep Tayyip Erdogan accuses of having staged a 2016 failed military coup.
Iran, Saudi Arabia and Turkey’s identification of Kashmir as a battleground points to the increased importance they attribute to South and by extension Central Asia. In a twist of irony, Turkish president Recep Tayyip Erdogan appears to be embracing the Sufi Menzil sect, one of the largest and most powerful Sufi orders in Turkey that is far more liberal than Saudi Arabia’s ultra-conservatism but shares with Madkhalism a rejection of politics.
Menzil Sufis have filled vacancies in the government bureaucracy and security services created by Erdogan’s mass purge in the wake of the failed coup of alleged followers of Gulen, according to journalist Timur Soykan, who recently published a book on a more controversial Sufi order.
Like Madkhalis, Menzils, with a history of support for the Turkish state and its military, potentially could serve as anti-dotes to Iranian Shiites’ activism in places like Kashmir where Iran is targeting the Shiite minority who account for 15 per cent of the region’s population.
Iran and Turkey’s emphasis on nationalism rather than religion compensates to some degree for Saudi Arabia’s first starter advantage, allowing Iran in particular to make significant inroads in Kashmir. Portraits of Iran’s late spiritual leader, Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, loom large on billboards in Shiite neighbourhoods whose streets are named after Shiite martyrs. Saudi Arabia’s execution in 2016 of a prominent Shiite cleric sparked anti-Saudi protests in Kashmir.
Unlike Iran, Turkey, eager to expand economic cooperation with India, has restricted its focus in Kashmir to verbal support in international fora rather than the funding of mosques and/or schools. That has not stopped separatist groups from embracing Erdogan even if that doesn’t challenge Saudi influence on the ground.
Indian journalist Asit Jolly estimated as far back as 2011 that 15 per cent of Kashmir’s population was affiliated with some 700 Saudi-inspired ultra-conservative mosques. A Sufi organization put the figure ten times higher. Ahl-e-Hadith, South Asia’s oldest Saudi-backed religious group, is believed to have funded some 150 schools, colleges, orphanages, clinics and medical diagnostic centres in Kashmir.
“Practically every village along the picturesque, poplar-lined, 60-km stretch northwest of Srinagar towards Gulmarg has one or more Ahl-e-Hadith-funded mosques. The new mosques and their attendant madrassas make for a contrasting picture with the hundreds of dilapidated mosques built over centuries in the age-old Sufi tradition,” Jolly reported.
"The Wahhabi influence is not new to Kashmir as followers of this Islamic practice have been there since the last 100 years. But the phenomenal growth in their influence and their far and wide reach now can be attributed only to the funding the local 'Ahle Hadith' have got from Saudi Arabia in the last 30 years," said an Indian intelligence official more recently.
Added analyst Abhinav Pandya: “Kashmir is becoming the ground zero for a new geopolitical race for influence: Iran and Turkey have deep, sometimes overlapping interests, Saudi Arabia wants to ensure a return on its financial and ideological investment… The question is whether these states…will weaponize those supporters in a future proxy conflict between themselves, or between separatists and India itself.”
Note: This article was originally published in the blog, The Turbulent World of Middle East Soccer and has been reproduced under arrangement. Web link
James M. Dorsey is a Senior Fellow at the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies as Nanyang Technological University in Singapore, co-director of the Institute of Fan Culture of the University of Würzburg, and the author of the blog, The Turbulent World of Middle East Soccer. Email: jmdorsey@questfze.com
A little acknowledged provision of the 2015 international agreement that curbed Iran’s nuclear.....
Religion scholar Esra Ozyurek has a knack for identifying trends that ring warning bells about where.....
A projected sharp reduction in trade between the United States and China in the next two years coupl.....
Public debates about China’s Middle East policy are as much internal Chinese discussions as th.....
Saudi Arabia has taken multiple steps to polish its tarnished image in advance of this weekend&rsquo.....
An Emirati offer to invest in Israel’s most controversial soccer club could serve as a figurat.....
A close read of the agreement between the United Arab Emirates and Israel suggests that the Jewish s.....
A rift between Pakistan and Saudi Arabia throws into sharp relief deepening fissures in the Muslim w.....
Rare polling of public opinion in Saudi Arabia suggests that Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman may be.....
China is contemplating greater political engagement in the Middle East in what would constitute a br.....
Europe is progressively being sucked into the Middle East and North Africa’s myriad conflicts......
China looms large as a potentially key player alongside Russia and Iran in President Bashas al-Assad.....
Civilizationalist leaders, who seek religious legitimacy, cater to a religious support base or initi.....
A decision by the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) and non-OPEC producers like R.....
The Coronavirus pandemic points a finger not only at the colossal global collapse of responsible pub.....
Syria’s announcement of its first COVID-19 case highlights the public health threat posed by w.....
The fight in this week’s Democratic primaries may have been about who confronts Donald J. Trum.....
A podcast version of this story is available on Sound cloud, ITunes, Spotify, Stitcher, Tune In, Spe.....
Saudi Arabia may have been getting more than it bargained for when authorities in Khujand, Tajikista.....
At the core of US president Donald J. Trump’s maximum pressure campaign against Iran lies the .....
The Iranian port city of Bandar-e-Mahshahr has emerged as the scene of some of the worst violence in.....
Saudi efforts to negotiate an end to the Yemen war in a bid to open a dialogue with Iran could call .....
China is manoeuvring to avoid being sucked into the Middle East’s numerous disputes amid mount.....
Fears of a potential military conflict with Iran may have opened the door to a Saudi-Iranian dialogu.....
By the law of unintended consequences, US President Donald J. Trump’s mix of uncritical and cy.....
Little suggests that fabulously wealthy Gulf States and their Middle Eastern and North African benef.....
A controversial former security official and Abu Dhabi-based political operator, Mohammed Dahlan, ha.....
Russia, backed by China, hoping to exploit mounting doubts in the Gulf about the reliability of the .....
China and Russia are as much allies as they are rivals. A joint Tajik-Chinese military exercise in a.....
These are tough times for Saudi Arabia. The drama enveloping the killing of journalist Jamal Khas.....
Saudi plans to become a major gas exporter within a decade raise questions about what the .....
A Turkish-Chinese spat as a result of Turkish criticism of China’s crackdown on Turkic Mu.....
This week’s suicide attack on Revolutionary Guards in Iran’s south-eastern province of S.....
Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman’s three-nation tour of Asia is as much about demonstrat.....
It may be reading tea leaves but analysis of the walk-up to Saudi crown prince Mohammed bin Salman&r.....
Alarm bells went off last September in Washington's corridors of power when John Bolton&rsq.....
US President Donald J. Trump’s threat to devastate Turkey’s economy if Turkish troo.....
Pakistan is traversing minefields as it concludes agreements on investment, balance of payments supp.....
A heavy soup made of pulled noodles, meat, and vegetables symbolizes Central Asia’s close cult.....
As far as Gulf leaders are concerned, President Donald J. Trump demonstrated with his announced.....
When President Recep Tayyip Erdogan recently declared that Turkey was “the only country that c.....
A draft US Senate resolution describing Saudi policy in the Middle East as a "wrecking ball&quo.....
As Saudi crown prince Mohammed bin Salman tours friendly Arab nations in advance of the Group of 20 .....
When Saudi General Khalid bin Sultan bin Abdul Aziz went shopping in the late 1980s for Chinese medi.....
Pakistani Prime Minister Imran Khan lands in Beijing on November 3, the latest head of government to.....
Saudi Arabia and Turkey, despite being on opposite sides of Middle Eastern divides, are cooperating .....
It’s easy to dismiss Iranian denunciations of the United States and its Middle Eastern allies .....
An attack on a military parade in the southern Iranian city of Ahwaz is likely to prompt Iranian ret.....
A Financial Action Task Force (FATF) report criticizing Saudi Arabia’s anti-money laundering a.....
Desperate for funding to fend off a financial crisis fuelled in part by mounting debt to China, Paki.....
Iran has raised the spectre of a US-Saudi effort to destabilize the country by exploiting .....
A possible ceasefire between Israel and Hamas, the Islamist group that controls the Gaza S.....
With multiple Middle Eastern disputes threatening to spill out of control, United Arab Emirates mini.....
Embattled former Malaysian Prime Minister Najib Razak was the main loser in last month&rsq.....
Lurking in the background of a Saudi-Moroccan spat over World Cup hosting rights and the Gulf crisis.....
Amid ever closer cooperation with Saudi Arabia, Israel’s military appears to be adopting the k.....
Mounting anger and discontent is simmering across the Arab world much like it did in the w.....
Argentina’s cancellation of a friendly against Israel because of Israeli attempts to exploit t.....
Conventional wisdom has it that China stands to benefit from the US withdrawal from the 2015 interna.....
Saudi Arabia’s bitter rivalry with Iran has spilled onto Asian soccer pitches with t.....
A controversy in Algeria over the growing popularity of Saudi-inspired Salafi scholars spotlights th.....
Subtle shifts in Chinese energy imports suggest that China may be able to exert influence in the Mid.....
Egyptian general-turned-president Abdel Fattah Al-Sisi won a second term virtually unchallenged in w.....
Protests have erupted in Iran’s oil-rich province of Khuzestan barely three months after the I.....
Debilitating hostility between Saudi Arabia and Iran is about lots of things, not least who will hav.....
Saudi Arabia, in an indication that it is serious about shaving off the sharp edges of its Sunni Mus.....
The Middle East has a knack for sucking external powers into its conflicts. China’s ventures i.....
A Saudi draft law could constitute a first indication that Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman’s .....
Turkish allegations of Saudi, Emirati and Egyptian support for the outlawed Kurdish Workers Party (P.....
Prominent US constitutional lawyer and scholar Alan M. Dershowitz raised eyebrows when he described .....
Plans to open a Salafi missionary centre in the Yemeni province of Al Mahrah on the border with Oman.....
If week-long anti-government protests in Iran exposed the Islamic republic’s deep-se.....
Kuwaiti billionaire Maan al-Sanea should have seen it coming after Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin S.....
Long-standing Saudi efforts to dominate the pan-Arab media landscape appear to have moved into high .....