Soon to enter its fourth month, the Russian invasion of Ukraine has made irreversible damages to global norms and order. There were similar occurrences in the past when national and regional developments threatened to weaken the rules-based order. Irrespective of their actual behaviours, great powers at least offered lip service to rules, norms and peaceful resolution of disputes. Not anymore. Diplomacy, soft power and morality are replaced by the re-emergence of raw military power. Only great powers write the international order—but since times immemorial, they have never been accountable for the very laws they formulate. Some justify aggression in the name of international peace and security, and others brandish narrow national interests. Either way, the redlines and punishment mechanisms are always the prerogative of the great powers. And Ukraine is the latest example.
Russia's two-decade-old economic revival has now taken an ominous militant form. Even if the eastward expansion of NATO is an existential threat, the way President Vladimir Putin sought to challenge it is a warning for other great powers and vulnerable smaller countries; great power will continue to rewrite the international order, and weaker ones are condemned to suffer the consequences. This asymmetrical order was not the dream of the Yalta conference, which sought to end the scourge of wars.
Two, the cavalier manner several public figures flag the possibility of World War III, and nuclear confrontation, should dispel any notions of international norms. In the past, only maverick leaders made such statements filled with bravado. One can’t escape this uncomfortable question: Was Ukraine foolish and short-sighted to give up and destroy its nuclear weapons in 1994 and join the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) as a non-nuclear-weapon state, just four years before the South Asian tests? Similar questions were raised over North Korea and Iraq. Now the Russian invasion of non-nuclear and helpless Ukraine sends an unmistakable message to hardliners in Iran: giving up the nuclear option or compromising enrichments will be an open invitation for external interventions in the Islamic republic.
Three, the Ukraine crisis underscored individual and collective hypocrisies. Legitimising the Russian invasion has unintended consequences. Saddam Hussein justified his invasion of Kuwait on the grounds of the latter siphoning off Iraqi oil through slant drilling. Now Putin sees NATO expansion as a redline that must not be crossed. Like individuals, nations are also short-sighted; the Crimean crisis of 2014 should have warned the Western strategic community of the Russian capabilities and calculations. Even if the political leaders were indulging in wishful thinking, there should have been plans for the worst-case scenario. Unfortunately, Washington did not do its homework before contemplating the expansion of NATO so close to the Russian heartland.
Four, as the organisation of sovereign states, the UN is not a perfect body. Yet, it has been striving to limit conflicts and move the world towards a more equitable order based on justice. The Ukraine crisis has pushed the UN back by several decades. In 1956, the UNSC was paralysed over the Suez crisis, as Britain and France, the major invaders of Egypt (along with Israel), were permanent members. Hence, the issue moved to the UN General Assembly, which overwhelmingly condemned and isolated the former colonial powers. However, the real force was US President Dwight Eisenhower, who strong armed and reversed the tripartite aggression. The situation is different today. Backed by China, Russia has paralysed the UNSC, and the UN General Assembly is ineffective without a global hegemon. International condemnation and isolation of Russia make headlines but are not sufficient to influence Putin.
Five, the Ukraine crisis reminds us of the flip sides of leaders with unbridled powers. As the invasion drags on, Russia's lack of pre-war preparation is visible. The invasion was not a well-planned military strategy, and Russian generals were perhaps bullied into submitting to political diktats. If regime change in Ukraine was the goal, the Russian generals are executing it badly. Since the days of Carthage, wars have had one golden rule: you can initiate a war, but you can’t write its end.
Six, popular and intellectual anti-Americanism has paved the way for widespread justification of the Russian invasion. While the crisis has exposed the policy limitations of the US and the West, any move to rationalise the Russian action has one danger. Will the Ukraine crisis be a carte blanche for similar actions by other powers vis-à-vis their hapless neighbours? In short, will Putin be a ‘precedent’ for Chinese President Xi Jinping to enforce his will on Taiwan?
Seven, uncertainties of the final outcome have compelled several countries, including India, to take refuge under political realism and temporarily bury core issues like the inviolability of sovereignty and territorial integrity. Instead, they settle for hedging to minimise the negatives and maximise their gains. Instead, this crisis should be an opportunity to explore and expand policy choices for the future.
With neither side prepared to climb down, an early end to the Ukraine crisis seems elusive. Meanwhile, without a serious political implosion in either country, the world is condemned to endure the political, economic and diplomatic consequences of the crisis and the systematic dismantling of the post-World War II international order.
Note: This article was originally published in The New Indian Express on 20 May 2022 and has been reproduced with the permission of the author. Web Link
As part of its editorial policy, the MEI@ND standardizes spelling and date formats to make the text uniformly accessible and stylistically consistent. The views expressed here are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views/positions of the MEI@ND. Editor, MEI@ND: P R Kumaraswamy
Professor P R Kumaraswamy is Honorary Director of MEI@ND.
The magnitude of the missile attack on Israel carried out by Iran in the early hours of Sunday was u.....
While the details are still emerging, the Hamas attacks from the Gaza Strip on Saturday were well pl.....
The Libyan controversy reminds us of the more significant problem facing Israel. While the scale and.....
64-0! It should be an impressive vote in any country, especially in Israel, where a simple parliamen.....
King Bibi is back! After one year in the Opposition, Benjamin Netanyahu, a close friend of Prime Min.....
Political instability is an integral and inseparable part of Israel’s landscape. For the fifth.....
Even by the Israeli standard of coalition fragility, the Bennett-Lapid government, which completed o.....
The visit of Israeli Prime Minister Naftali Bennett to India scheduled for last week had to be cance.....
The drone attack on Abu Dhabi on Monday (January 17) by the Houthi rebels marks a major escalation o.....
Of late, Israel-Iran shadow-boxing has been getting ominous. If Israel’s diplomatic offensive .....
In early November, Moscow hosted Mohammed Dahlan, a former right-hand man of Palestinian leader Yass.....
Nearly three decades after Prime Minister P V Narasimha Rao broke from the past and normalised relat.....
Earlier it was Pakistan and now China. So whatever India does and does not do externally has to be l.....
In several ways, the Taliban takeover of Afghanistan can be a game-changer in India’s worldvie.....
The Taliban takeover and its fallout exposed the limited diplomatic space for India in its immediate.....
Given the travel restrictions, local lockdown and sluggish economic revival, that over three lakh pe.....
Since 2005, some critical decisions over Iran have been taken by the MEA’s US Division. So que.....
“Bibi dethroned”. This is the expression used in the Israeli media to describe the forma.....
Despite having a woman prime minister in Golda Meir, female political representation in Israel has n.....
The most interesting aspect of the new Bennett-Lapid government in Israel is the emergence of Mansou.....
When it comes to mediating international crises, India’s track record is a mixed bag. In recen.....
Going by the Israeli media, it is clear that the arm-twisting by the Biden Administration forced the.....
Indeed, Hamas is better placed today than it was in January 2006 and the current round of violence i.....
While the international community wants de-escalation and an early end to the conflict, the chances .....
Ending the past silence, US President Joe Biden marked the Armenian Genocide Remembrance Day of Apri.....
The visit of Foreign Minister of Bahrain Abdullatif bin Rashid Al Zayani to India during 6-8 April r.....
By posthumously bestowing the Gandhi Peace Prize for 2019 upon Sultan Qaboos of Oman, New Delhi seek.....
Much to the displeasure and discomfort of Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman (more widely known .....
The nomination of Robert Malley, a veteran hand in Washington policy circles, as the Special Envoy f.....
The two-day visit of External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar to the United Arab Emirates last week is.....
United Arab Emirates’ (UAE) decision to normalise relations with Israel is the most dramatic e.....
Declaring victory moments after the polling ends has become the hallmark of Benjamin Netanyahu; and .....
Israel went to polls for the 23rd Knesset on 2nd March. The third parliamentary elections within one.....
With possible removal from office hanging over their heads, US President Donald Trump and Israeli Pr.....
US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo’s sudden and unexpected announcement regarding Israeli settl.....
US President Donald Trump’s decision on imposing sanctions on Turkey has rocked the ever-turbu.....
Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s two-day visit to the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia this week highligh.....
Prime Minister Narendra Modi's reported decision to postpone a planned visit to Turkey comes a c.....
With the sole and notable exception of Pakistan, India's relations with the wider Islamic world .....
For a long time, India’s relationship with its extended neighbourhood in the Persian Gulf was .....
The Israeli legislative or Knesset election last week has turned out to be a rerun of the 9 April on.....
Will 2019 see a third Knesset election? This question is going rounds in Israel as it faces the seco.....
When he called Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi to congratulate on his re-election with a landsli.....
The resounding re-election of Prime Minister Narendra Modi is a blessing for India's relat.....
Iran is back in the news and for all the wrong reasons. It has been the unnecessary third .....
During the close to a century of its existence, the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan has been, as former .....
In their eagerness to focus on and flag the de-hyphenation of the traditional Israel-Palestinian bin.....
In the closely scrutinised India-Israel relationship, there is little in the public domain that rema.....
You know what, it will go to the dustbin’ my articulate friend was blunt, brutal but.....
Balfour Declaration, A Century Later If one were to make a list of the most influential.....
Professor Bernard Lewis—a towering personality on the Middle Eastern academic landscape—.....
B orn in Poland on 2 August 1923, Szymon Persk who later Hebraised his name as Shimon Peres was the leader.....
W hat What began as a protest by a marginalized vegetable vendor in Sidi Bouzid in Tunisia soon spread lik.....